Which Design Choices can Reduce EMF Noise?
EMF noise generally refers to any noise that can be induced in a circuit or PCB by the electromagnetic field.
We generally think of EMF noise as radiated EMI, but it can also arise as conducted EMI.
EMF noise can pass between circuits within a board, or from outside a board. Some smart design and layout decisions can help you protect circuits from EMF noise.
This spectrum analyzer can be used to measure EMF noise.
Everything that happens in electronics is related back to the behavior of the electromagnetic field (EMF). From the intentional passage of signals between components to unintended reception of noise, all electronics are designed to have some level of control over the EMF. In effect, EMF noise occurs when the product designer has not exerted adequate control over the EMF.
PCB design is not about controlling the EMF directly, but rather making some smart layout decisions that govern how a device responds to the EMF. Noise induced by the EMF can occur via radiation from an external source, or by being conducted between a noise source and a victim component. With some smart layout decisions, you can reduce the effect of both types of EMF noise in your system.
Conducted vs. Radiated EMF Noise
All noise is passed into a circuit as either conducted or radiated EMF noise. Either noise present on one component passes through conductors into a victim component (conducted EMI), or it is emitted from one component and is received like a typical radio signal. Depending on the board’s application and deployment environment, designers need to decide which layout choices are best for preventing noise from impacting components and signals in their PCB.
There are two general approaches for dealing with both types of noise:
Filter out the noise with a filter circuit or a choke.
Prevent noise from passing into a victim circuit or interconnect.
A comprehensive approach to reducing EMF noise has always been challenging for designers, and the challenges will only increase as signal speeds and frequencies increase. Depending on the signal bandwidth and frequency range, some layout and component choices may be more ideal than others for suppressing EMF noise.
Radiated EMF Noise
Radiated EMF noise can be received inductively in any closed circuit loop on your PCB, through the electric field via parasitic capacitance, or through floating conductors (e.g., an ungrounded heat sink) that act as antennas. The simplest defense is to block any radiated EMF from inducing appreciable noise in a circuit. In other words, use something to absorb radiation, cause any received radiation to interfere with itself destructively, or reduce any radiation through the use of shielding.
To help suppress reception of radiation in a circuit block, you can use the following strategies:
Shielding cans. This ranges from metal shielding cans to placement of specialized bandgap structures that provide high isolation.
Guard traces and vias. This is a simple way to provide some isolation between traces, components, and circuit blocks. Electrically, this adjusts parasitics near an interconnect.
Electronic bandgap (EBG) structures. An EBG structure uses an array of polygons to provide high isolation within a desired bandwidth. These structures are commonly used in smartphones and will become more common in high-frequency RF products.
Conformal coatings. A conformal coating can provide some absorption at certain high frequencies. An absorbing conformal coating is known to suppress edge emissions from cavity resonances at mmWave frequencies.
Increase trace spacing. This basic layout option helps reduce crosstalk between traces by reducing the field strength seen at a victim trace.
Decrease ground-to-trace separation. This also combats inductive crosstalk, as well as reception of radiation from external EMF sources by decreasing an interconnect’s parasitic loop inductance.
Use tied ground pour and planes. This helps build greater shielding around traces in your system and helps prevent reception of radiation from external sources.
All of these choices are helpful for addressing EMI from various sources. Because reception of electromagnetic radiation by most elements in your system is reciprocal, these choices can also help you pass EMC by reducing radiated EMF. Some of these strategies are common in RF products to reduce EMF noise passing between circuit blocks and to the exterior of the device.
These copper structures around the RFFE components and baseband chip provide shielding against radiated EMI between circuit blocks.
Conducted EMF Noise
Conducted EMF noise often originates as radiated EMF that is received in an interconnect, after which it propagates to another component. A prime example is crosstalk, which starts as radiation from another trace but then propagates into an upstream or downstream component. Another example is noise from return currents in a reference plane, where ferrites can receive common-mode noise through their parasitics and propagate this noise to other components.
For these noise sources, you can choose between three options:
Filtering. Custom filter circuits can provide high rolloff attenuation in a specific range of frequencies, so this is best used to suppress noise within a certain bandwidth.
Common-mode or differential-mode chokes. In routing protocols like MII/RMII, or on AC mains, ferrite chokes are normally used to cancel out common-mode noise.
Properly plan return paths. Because some conducted EMI can originate as noise from return paths, all return paths should be properly planned to prevent noise from coupling back into an upstream circuit. As an example, this is one problem that produces nonlinear instability in high-frequency amplifiers and excess common-mode noise in Ethernet routing.
Use components that require differential pairs. Most high-speed routing protocols use differential pairs, which has largely eliminated common-mode noise concerns. In this case, you only need to worry about differential crosstalk.
Conducted noise has long been a problem because some of the only solutions include filtration, common-mode or differential-mode chokes (can’t be done simultaneously), and equalization. The best option you have is to use best layout practices and software to prevent radiated EMF noise from being converted to conducted noise.
If you’d like to keep up-to-date with our System Analysis content, sign-up for our newsletter curating resources on current trends and innovations. If you’re looking to learn more about how Cadence has the solution for you, talk to us and our team of experts.