When Your Component Is Unavailable: Alternates, Last Buys, and Counterfeits
3 www.cadence.com
Figure 1: Capacitance loss under DC bias varies significantly by dielectric grade. At rated voltage, C0G exhibits negligible loss, X7R loses
approximately 15%, X5R approximately 25%, Z5U approximately 55%, and Y5V up to 80%. The difference between grades is not captured in
parametric search. It is encoded in the dielectric code of the manufacturer part number and requires checking the full MPN or datasheet
before approving an alternate.
f
Oscillators and crystals: frequency tolerance, aging, and load capacitance specifications must all match. A crystal
alternate with the same nominal frequency but different load capacitance will run the oscillator circuit off-frequency unless
the load capacitors are adjusted.
f
Optocouplers: current transfer ratio (CTR) varies significantly between manufacturers even for the same part number
family. An alternate with a lower CTR minimum may cause the output stage to fail to switch properly at the boundary
conditions of the design.
Assembly process compatibility
The alternate part must survive your specific assembly process, not a generic SMT process. Parameters to verify:
f
Moisture sensitivity level (MSL): an alternate with a higher MSL rating than the primary source requires more stringent floor
life management. A part rated MSL 3 replacing an MSL 1 part changes the assembly process requirements.
f
Reflow profile compatibility: confirm the alternate is rated for the peak temperature and time above liquidus of the solder
profile in use, particularly for lead-free processes where peak temperatures approach component limits.
f
Handling requirements: some alternates have different ESD sensitivity ratings. An alternate rated for higher ESD sensitivity
requires additional handling precautions in the assembly line.
1.2 A Practical Alternate Qualification Process
A qualification process for an alternate component should be proportional to the risk profile of the component and its role in
the design. A general-purpose bypass capacitor warrants a different level of scrutiny than a sole-sourced power management
IC in a safety-relevant circuit.
